# After the first draft: how to map your novel and plan the second draft

> What to do after a first draft: map what happens, set it against a structure, list the mismatches and plan a retyped second draft. A worked example.

Source: https://writermorph.com/articles/after-the-first-draft/

November ends on Monday the 30th, and with it the month of fast drafting that many novelists still keep, in community-run challenges, with friends or on their own. If you took part, you are about to own a draft that is long, uneven and probably unfinished. This article shows what to do with it in a single evening: map what the draft actually contains, set that map against a structure, list where the two disagree, and turn the list into a plan for the second draft.

The method comes from the novelist Matt Bell. The worked example is The Salt Archive, a sample mystery that comes with WriterMorph and that you can [download](https://writermorph.com/samples/) to follow along. It is a made-up book, built to look like a real one in progress.

## The method: map the draft before you change it

In his craft book [*Refuse to Be Done*](https://sohopress.com/books/refuse-to-be-done/) (Soho Press, 2022), Bell gives each of a novel's three drafts a different job. The first draft is for discovery: you write to find out what the book is. The second draft rebuilds it on purpose. Between the two sits a mapping exercise, which he also published as [Exercise #28, "Mapping the First Draft"](https://mattbell.substack.com/p/refuse-to-be-done-launch-day-exercise):

1. Make a beat sheet of the main storyline. Record only events, or in his words, "map only the action of the time narrated". Backstory and themes stay out.
2. Set that beat sheet against a structure: three acts, a braided narrative, Freytag's pyramid or another of your choosing.
3. Note every place where the draft and the structure disagree. Each one points to a change: a missing scene, a storyline to add, pacing to fix.
4. Revise the outline toward the shape you want. That outline is the plan for draft two.

Then comes the step most writers resist. Bell recommends retyping the second draft from scratch instead of editing the old file. In an [interview with Publishers Weekly](https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/authors/interviews/article/88847-matt-bell-explains-how-to-write-a-novel-in-three-drafts.html) he explained that the over-explaining a first draft does for its writer becomes obvious once you have to type it again. The book also warns that the second draft can take about as long as the first. That is normal, not a sign of failure.

## The draft we are mapping

The Salt Archive is a literary mystery in three acts. Mara Quill, an archivist, comes home to a North Sea harbor town after her father drowns and finds a ledger proving that ships lost in the storm of 1987 were sunk on purpose. The sample is unfinished on purpose, which makes it a fair stand-in for a November draft:

| Act | Scenes | State of the draft |
|---|---|---|
| Act I | 7 | Written: 684 to 799 words a scene |
| Act II | 11 | Two full scenes; the rest are partial drafts of 107 to 289 words |
| Act III | 6 | Scene summaries of about 100 words each |

The binder counts 9,217 words. Four scenes are marked Final, five Done, four Draft, three In Progress and eight To Do. In other words: a strong opening, a thinning middle and an ending that exists only as notes.

## Step 1: Freeze the first draft

Before you change anything, make sure nothing can be lost. In WriterMorph's binder, select every scene (click the first, Shift-click the last), right-click and choose **Take Snapshots**: each scene keeps a copy of its text as it is tonight, which you can compare or restore later from the Inspector's **Snapshots** tab. Then choose **File › Back Up › Back Up Now**. Now you can cut freely.

## Step 2: Map only what happens

A map is only as good as its entries, and most first-draft synopses describe a mood ("Mara feels lost") instead of an event ("Mara opens her father's letter"). Choose **View › Writer Timeline** (⌥⌘T) and click **Outline**: the scenes appear grouped by act, each with its synopsis, so the book reads like a summary of itself. Rewrite any synopsis that does not say what happens and what changes. The **Stats** panel lists, under **Needs attention**, the scenes with no summary yet.

![The Writer Timeline in Outline view for The Salt Archive: the chapters of Act One in the sidebar with their beats, and on the right the synopses of Low Water, The Tab on the Wall, A Hundred Years Back and Accidental Death, each with its point of view, place, story time and beat.](https://writermorph.com/media/h-wt-outline.webp "The Outline view: the draft as one event per scene.")

Mapped like this, Act I of The Salt Archive is seven events. Mara arrives with an unopened letter from her dead father. Her sister Edie greets her with six years of grievance, and that night Mara opens the letter. The letter's riddle leads her to an 1887 harbor ledger that cannot be as old as it looks. A detective who has already closed her father's drowning as an accident meets her. A flashback shows the lighthouse keeper watching three ships put out into the 1987 gale. At the wake, the shipping magnate Harlan Voss offers to restore the archive. Late that night, Mara hides in the stacks while a stranger searches the 1887 shelf. Every one of them changes what someone knows or wants. That is what a working map looks like.

## Step 3: Set the map against a structure

The sample uses the Three Act Structure: ten beats from Setup to Resolution, and every scene carries one. In the Writer Timeline, the **Plot Board**'s **Structure** menu shows the beats above the scenes; the **Tension** panel draws the book's curve, as in the picture at the top.

For a measurement, add the **Beat Sheet Tracker** page. It is a Live Page, a Labs feature: turn on **Turn HTML pages into small apps (Live Pages)** in **Settings › Labs**, then choose **New ▾ › Live Page ▸ › Examples ▸** in the sidebar; the Beat Sheet Tracker is in the Fiction submenu. It places each scene where it falls in the book and compares that with where the beat sheet expects each beat.

![The Beat Sheet Tracker Live Page for The Salt Archive: 10 of 10 beats covered, 24 of 24 scenes with a beat, 2 of 10 beats on cue, the biggest drift +35 points for the First Pinch Point, and the busiest beat Rising Action with 8 scenes, above a pacing chart in which Act I takes up more than half of the words written.](https://writermorph.com/media/lp-beat-sheet-tracker.webp "The Beat Sheet Tracker: where each beat falls, by words written.")

For The Salt Archive the verdict is mixed. Every beat has a scene and every scene has a beat. But only 2 of the 10 beats fall where the template expects them, the First Pinch Point lands 35 points late, and Rising Action holds 8 scenes, more than three times the average. The cause is plain once you look at the chart: Act I holds more than half of the 9,217 words.

## Step 4: List the mismatches, then decide

Read these numbers as questions. Measured on a draft whose ending is still in note form, they mostly report that the ending has not been written. Switch the tracker from **Words written** to **Scene count** to see the order without the distortion of length. Then write the list. For The Salt Archive, it could read like this:

- **The weight of Act I.** Act I runs about 740 words a scene; once Act II and Act III are written at that density, much of the late drift will fix itself. The decision: don't cut Act I to make the chart look right.
- **The sag in the middle.** The tension curve drops twice in Act II: to 4 at The Keeper's Door, straight after the intruder scene at 7, and to 4 at The Biscuit Tin, just before the midpoint. The decision: in the keeper's scene his refusal has to cost Mara something; the survivor's letters that a young journalist brings in The Biscuit Tin move after Pilotage, Special, where they confirm the midpoint instead of delaying it.
- **The detective's thread.** Ansel Roe has the point of view in scenes 4, 10, 15, 19 and 22, so after his first scene he is gone for five. The decision: give him a short scene among the first scenes of Act II, after the keeper refuses to talk.
- **Act III.** Six summaries of about 100 words. The decision: these are the outline for the ending; check each against the beat it carries before writing a word.

These decisions are examples, not the only right answers. The point of the list is that every change in the second draft has a reason you wrote down.

Now revise the outline itself. Drag scenes into their new order on the **Corkboard** (⌘2). Add a missing scene where it belongs: in the Writer Timeline's **Story Map**, right-click an empty cell and choose **New scene here**, then write its synopsis before anything else. Turn each larger change into a task card with **Insert › New Task Card**, so the plan stays next to the book.

## Step 5: Retype the second draft beside the first

Retyping a whole novel sounds slow, and it is. It is also the step that changes the most, because you have to decide about every sentence again. Set up the screen so you can read the old scene while you write the new one:

1. Right-click a scene in the binder and choose **Duplicate**. The copy has the same text, synopsis and properties, and sits just below the original. The copy is your first-draft text; the original is the scene you will rewrite.
2. Choose **View › Editor Layout › Split Vertically**. Open the copy in the left pane and click the lock button in its header (or **View › Editor Layout › Lock in Place**), so clicks in the binder no longer change it.
3. Open the original in the right pane, select all its text and delete it. Write the scene again from the revised outline, reading from the left. Retype; don't paste.
4. When a scene is done, select the copies, choose **Group into New Folder**, call the folder First draft, and choose **Documents › Include in Compile (toggle)** so they stay out of the book.

![Manuscript Mode in The Salt Archive with the editor split vertically: the binder of Act I, Act II and Act III on the left, the scene A Hundred Years Back open in two panes side by side, and the Inspector with the scene's synopsis on the right.](https://writermorph.com/media/h-ms-split.webp "A vertical split: the old scene on one side, the new one on the other.")

For The Salt Archive, the order of work follows from the list: rewrite Act I tighter, write the middle of Act II for the first time with the two sags fixed, then turn the six summaries of Act III into scenes. Mark each scene **Revision** in its status as you finish it, so the binder shows how far the second draft has come.

When the second draft is done, it is time for the edits that work on sentences, in passes from big to small; that part is in [how to edit a novel](https://writermorph.com/articles/how-to-edit-a-novel/). Tonight, spend one evening on the map and the list, and leave the retyping for tomorrow.
