WriterMorphby HiMorph® Download on the Mac App Store
EN (Language: English)

How long should a novel be? Word counts by genre, and whether 50,000 is enough

A November draft ends at 50,000 words, and the first question is whether that is a book. Here are the lengths that count as a novel, the ranges agents expect in each genre, what to do with a draft that is too short or too long, and how to keep count in WriterMorph.

The 30-Day Novel Challenge Live Page in The Salt Archive demo, set to 50,000 words in 30 days. Tiles show 21,911 words so far, 44% finished and a projected finish on 7 December, above a calendar of the month with each day's words, green on the days that reached the target, and a list of milestones from 10,000 to 50,000 words.The 30-Day Novel Challenge Live Page in The Salt Archive demo, set to 50,000 words in 30 days. Tiles show 21,911 words so far, 44% finished and a projected finish on 7 December, above a calendar of the month with each day's words, green on the days that reached the target, and a list of milestones from 10,000 to 50,000 words.
A 50,000-word challenge as a calendar of daily words, with the sample data of a demo project.

At the end of November a lot of writers have a draft of about 50,000 words and the same question: is this a novel, or half of one? The honest answer is that it depends on who is asking. By the rules of the major awards, 50,000 words is a novel. For most agents and publishers it is short, and how short depends on the genre.

This article gives the numbers: what counts as a novel, what the trade expects in each category, what the lengths of well-known books are, and what to do when your draft comes out under or over. The last part shows how to count and plan by length in WriterMorph.

What counts as a novel

The clearest definitions come from awards, which have to draw lines. The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association uses these for its Nebula Awards, and the Hugo Awards draw the same lines:

Form Words
Short story Under 7,500
Novelette 7,500 to 17,500
Novella 17,500 to 40,000
Novel 40,000 or more

So a 50,000-word draft is a novel, and a short one. That puts it in good company. The Great Gatsby runs to about 47,000 words and Fahrenheit 451 to about 46,000.

What agents and publishers expect, by genre

Being a novel and being a length that publishers buy from a new author are different things. In her guide to query letters, the publishing expert Jane Friedman calls 80,000 words the industry standard for a debut novel, puts the minimum for most novels at 50,000, and warns that anything beyond 120,000 is a hard sell. A much-quoted Writer's Digest guide to word counts breaks this down by category:

Category The safest range Notes
Literary and mainstream fiction, romance, mystery, thriller, horror 80,000 to 90,000 70,000 to 110,000 is the outer range; below or above it is a risk
Science fiction and fantasy 100,000 to 115,000 90,000 to 124,000 is the outer range
Young adult 55,000 to 80,000 The most flexible category; some run a little over 80,000
Middle grade 20,000 to 55,000 20,000 to 35,000 for younger readers, 40,000 to 55,000 for upper middle grade
Westerns 50,000 to 80,000 About 65,000 is a solid target
Memoir 80,000 to 90,000 The same as for a novel

Read the table with three cautions:

Science fiction and fantasy run longer because a new world has to be built on the page. Books for younger readers run shorter, and the range moves with the age of the reader.

Well-known books, for scale

Counts differ a little with the edition and the way of counting, so take these as round figures.

Book Words, about
Fahrenheit 451, Ray Bradbury 46,000
The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald 47,000
Frankenstein, Mary Shelley 75,000
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, J. K. Rowling 77,000
Pride and Prejudice, Jane Austen 122,000

In manuscript format, with 12-point type and double spacing, a page holds roughly 250 to 300 words, so an 80,000-word novel is about 270 to 320 manuscript pages.

If your draft is 50,000 words

A fast first draft is usually a skeleton. It has the events and little else, and the second draft makes it longer. Before you decide the book is too short, look at what a quick draft tends to leave out:

Don't pad. Every word you add should belong to a scene that changes something. A useful check is to list your scenes by act and count the words in each act: the short act is where the missing material is. After the first draft shows how to map a finished draft scene by scene.

There is another possibility. The story may be complete at its present length, and then you have a novella or a book for younger readers. Decide which book it is before you revise, because the revision is different.

If your draft is too long

A draft of 140,000 words in a category that expects 90,000 can't be fixed one adjective at a time. Cut in this order:

  1. Structure. Remove a subplot, merge two minor characters, start the story later, end it sooner. One decision here can take out 15,000 words.
  2. Scenes. Find scenes that do the same job twice, such as two arguments about the same thing or two journeys in which nothing changes, and keep the better one.
  3. Lines. Only then cut within scenes. Stephen King's formula in On Writing is that the second draft is the first draft minus ten per cent.

Splitting the book in two is rarely the answer for a debut. The first volume has to stand as a complete story, and half a story with a break in the middle does not.

Count the right thing

Word counts in WriterMorph

Set the length you are aiming for

Choose Project › Show Project Targets (⇧⌘T) and enter a Manuscript target: the middle of your category's range is a sensible first number. Any card or document can have its own word target too, with a progress bar on the card, in the Outliner and in the Properties panel. If you give each scene a target, a scene that runs to twice its length shows up while you are still writing it.

See where the words are

The binder shows each scene's word count next to its title. In the Writer Timeline (View › Writer Timeline, ⌥⌘T), the Progress view sets every chapter against its target, and Stats opens Book Stats, which counts scenes, plotlines, filled beats and words, with breakdowns by act, scene type, character and place. The breakdown by act shows at a glance when one act is much thinner than the others.

Book Stats for The Salt Archive: 33 scenes, 4 plotlines, 10 of 10 beats filled, 9,217 words and an average tension of 5.6 with 24 of 33 rated, above a Tension by act chart showing Act One 3–7, Act Two 3–9 and Act Three 2–10Book Stats for The Salt Archive: 33 scenes, 4 plotlines, 10 of 10 beats filled, 9,217 words and an average tension of 5.6 with 24 of 33 rated, above a Tension by act chart showing Act One 3–7, Act Two 3–9 and Act Three 2–10
Book Stats for a sample mystery: scenes, plotlines, beats and words on one panel.

Project › Text Statistics & Word Frequency… counts words and sentences and gives the average sentence length, a readability score and the reading time, for one document, a selection or the whole manuscript. Project › Writing History… lists the words you wrote each day, and keeps Draft, the words written in the book, apart from Other, the words written in the rest of the project, so notes and outlines don't inflate the book's number.

The Text Statistics window for A Hundred Years Back: 799 words, 70 sentences, an average sentence of 11.4 words, readability 85, and a word frequency list led by mara, back, ledger and paper.The Text Statistics window for A Hundred Years Back: 799 words, 70 sentences, an average sentence of 11.4 words, readability 85, and a word frequency list led by mara, back, ledger and paper.
Text Statistics for one scene: words, sentences and the words it uses most.

Follow a challenge to the end

The page at the top of this article is the 30-Day Novel Challenge, one of the built-in Live Pages. It is set to 50,000 words from 1 November by default and shows your running total against the target, your streak, a projected finish and the words needed each day. Live Pages are a Labs feature: turn on Turn HTML pages into small apps (Live Pages) in Settings › Labs, then choose New ▾ › Live Page ▸ › Examples ▸ in the sidebar; the page is in the Writing & Publishing submenu. In the Fiction submenu, the Novel Dashboard draws each scene as a bar of its words against its target.

Cut and add without losing anything

Before a cutting pass, select your scenes in the binder, right-click and choose Take Snapshots; each scene keeps a copy of its text as it is that day. Then choose Format › Revision Mode and turn on Mark Deletions: what you delete stays visible, struck through, until you accept or reject it. To join two scenes that do the same job, select them and choose Documents › Merge (⇧⌘M). To give a new scene its own document, put the cursor where it should start and choose Documents › Split › Split at Selection (⌥⌘K). See Revisions, History and Snapshots.

A word count is a way of asking whether the story has the room it needs, and no more than that. Find your category's range, set a target in the middle of it, and let the revision decide the final number.

Other product names mentioned (e.g. Scrivener, Final Draft, Microsoft Word, Obsidian, Notion) are trademarks of their respective owners. They are used to describe compatibility or appear in customers' own words; WriterMorph is not affiliated with or endorsed by their owners.